Case Studies—By Industry
| Industry |
Links to Case Studies |
Oil & Gas |
|
Pulp & Paper |
|
Chemicals |
|
Utilities |
|
Metals/Mining |
|
Specialty Chemicals |
|
Cement |
|
Case Studies—By Type of Result
| Desired Result |
Examples |
Bottom-Line Benefits |
|
Energy Savings |
|
Production Increases |
|
New Plant Start-Up |
|
Enterprise-Wide Performance |
|
Quality/Variability Reduction |
|
Submit a Case Study from Your Company
Improve your professional recognition, and enhance your career.
Who knows? You might even be able to publish your story in a
major magazine! Click on the button at right to enter your case
study.
Columbian Chemicals Improves Process & Saves Energy
|
The Challenge:
Reduce energy costs and improve process variability across the
company.
The Solution:
PlantTriage installed at plants worldwide.
The Results
Over $1,000,000 saved. Almost immediate return on investment.
|
|
Watch the Video Case
Study. (3:50 minutes, WMV)
|
Kruger Paper saves 1 million annually
Watch the Video Case
Study. (12:06 minutes, WMV).
The Challenge:
Fast and efficient startup of new paper machine.
The Solution:
500 loop PlantTriage system.
The Result:
Solved many stability and startup problems resulting in:
- startup 4 months ahead of schedule
- 2% increase in efficiency 1 year before projected best-case
startup curves. Results in an on-going savings of over 1 million dollars per
year.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Kruger Wayagamack, Canada |
Paper mill |
Fast startup of paper machine |
PlantTriage software |
1 million annually |
Smurfit-Stone saves $280,000 per year!
Smurfit-Stone Container
Corporation produces paperboard/packaging products including
virgin and recycled container-board, coated and uncoated recycled
box-board and solid bleached sulfate and recycled cylinder-board, and
consumer packaging.
The Challenge: Steam Dryers
The humidity on the dry end of a paper machine was cycling
and causing high variability in the end product. The steam
supply was also cycling. On the steam dryers there are 3-10 drums
per section. Temperature is controlled by maintaining the pressure.
Each subsequent drum has higher temperature and pressure to dry the
paper further. If moisture in a section is high then you increase
drum temperature to bring it back. The steam from the previous drum
is re-used in the next drum to save energy.
The Solution:
ExperTune hysteresis and stiction test revealed bad response from the
positioner because of hysteresis and stiction. Using ExperTune
software, the service provider analyzed and diagnosed each valve, checked sizing, gain
and stiction. Smurfit repaired the valve problems pinpointed by
ExperTune and the service provider who then tuned the loops using ExperTune software.
The Result:
Smurfit Stone's profit increase was $280,000/year.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Smurfit-Stone |
Paper Mill |
Dry end valves, tuning |
ExperTune software and service |
$280,000/yr |
Customer Success Story:
Petro-Canada saves over $500,000!
Offshore Oil Processing. An offshore oil field is being developed
using a Floating Production Storage and Offloading vessel (FPSO).
This facility is a ship-shaped vessel with integrated oil storage.
The Challenge:
A new 900 foot long ship with oil separators on the ship. The ship
hooks up to the oil well, processes and offloads fuel to a tanker.
This is a 3 billion dollar project that produces 100,000 barrels per
day of oil. It is important to get the most out of this capital
investment by getting the ship up and running quickly and out to sea.
They did not want tuning to be a bottleneck in getting the ship started
up. There is $3 million dollars a day in revenue from this ship.
The Solution:
Petro Canada purchased ExperTune software and trained 2 different
crews in its use.
The Result:
ExperTune software conservatively saved at least 1/2 day of start-up
time. It probably saved 3 days of start-up time. 4 hours of start-up time
on this vessel is worth at least $500,000.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Petro-Canada |
Off-shore oil processing |
System start up |
ExperTune software and training |
at least $500,000 |
Customer Success Story:
Petro-Canada saves over $330,000 per year!
Petro-Canada: Refiners of
petroleum products, including gasolines, diesel oils, heating oils,
aviation fuels, heavy fuel oils, asphalts and feedstocks for
lubricants and petrochemicals.
The Challenge:
A crude unit was experiencing a persistent cycling problem. Because
of the magnitude of the cost savings associated with stabilizing the
unit, the plant installed and implemented an advanced model
prediction control package. This model predictive control package
was unable to get rid of the cycling problem.
The Solution:
Service personnel were brought in. The service provider trained the personnel
on using ExperTune software. Then they tested the regulatory control loops.
ExperTune software identified some valve problems (that were repaired) and
ExperTune software tuned the loops. 9% hysteresis and improper tuning was
found on a critical loop.
The Result:
The persistent cycling problem has been cured on the crude unit.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Petro-Canada |
Oil refining |
Persistent cycling |
ExperTune software and service |
$330,000 annually |
Customer Success Story:
Multinational Chemical Plant Sees Five-Fold Increase in Productivity!
The Challenge:
Increase productivity and efficiency.
The Solution:
PlantTriage software.
The Result:
A five-fold increase in productivity and double the life of the plant's
valves. ExperTune won the
2003 Plant Services Problem
Solver Award for this site.
According to Plant Services magazine "A major multinational
chemical processor with tens of thousands of instruments and valves is
receiving the benefits of five times the manpower by using PlantTriage
performance monitoring software. The system also helps double the life
of the company's valves."
Plant Services continues:
"By looking at the most important areas listed in the "Biggest Payback
Loop" list, the same maintenance people can oversee 10 times as many
controllers as before, since the controllers are prioritized based on
importance to the business."
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Multinational Chemical Company |
Chemicals |
Need to increase productivity and efficiency |
PlantTriage software |
Five-fold productivity increase. |
Alcan saves $200,000 per year!
Alcan Aluminum Limited: Mines,
processes, and refines bauxite.
The Challenge:
In the crushing plant sometimes 2 large rocks would be too much
energy for the system. Mechanical parts were wearing out fast -
bearings, motors, conveyors, etc. To overcome this, the plant ran at
low flow, but the production rate was slow.
The Solution:
Service provider personnel helped them re-design the system the using
constraint control. Now the feed flow control is based on the current
limits to the motors. ExperTune software was used to tune the newly
redesigned loops.
The Result:
Production rate is now faster, saving $200,000/year.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Alcan |
Mining |
Low production rate |
ExperTune software and service |
$200,000 per year |
The Challenge:
The temperature control on the kiln was not stable and was cycling.
Because of this energy was being wasted and they often tripped the
emergency shutdown (at 112 deg C), after which they would need to
start-up, and go through a lengthy recovery procedure.
The Solution:
Service provider personnel worked to improve the control in their Allen
Bradley Control Logix controller. The service provider made some adjustments
to the PID block and PLC programming.
Using ExperTune software they re-tuned the loops.
The Result:
Because of stable control, the operation was able to reduce the
operating setpoint. The average flow of natural gas was reduced from
875 Nm3/h to 831 Nm3/h—a 5% reduction. Now the operation
experiences very few shut-downs.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Mining Operation |
Natural Gas Kiln |
Costly shut-downs, wasted energy |
Service using ExperTune software |
$150,000 per year |
A Nuclear Plant in Pennsylvania saves $50,000 per year!
The Power Station is a two unit power plant located on 500 acres in
Pennsylvania. The two pressurized water reactors produced over 11
billion kWh in 2000.
The Challenge:
Running at low power, the plant loops were oscillating. The plant
runs at low power during start-up and shut-down.
The Solution:
The plant had previously replaced 3 valves on the feedwater flow to steam
generators. Using ExperTune, the service provider confirmed that valves were
working properly and tuned the controllers.
The Result:
$50,000/yr based on saved startup time/year.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Nuclear Power Plant |
Electric Utility |
Unstable start-up |
Service using ExperTune software |
$50,000 per year |
United Technologies saves over $50,000 per year!
United Technologies (UTX): Provides a broad
range of high-technology products and support services to customers
in the aerospace and building industries worldwide.
The Challenge:
This facility manufactures and tests fuel cells. Hydrogen, nitrogen
and carbon dioxide gas are blended in blending system that supplies
gas used to test the fuel cells. The system was unstable in automatic.
The Solution:
Service provider personnel adjusted the PLC configuration, control system
design, and re-tuned the loops.
The Result:
Stable control saving $50,000 per year.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| United Technologies |
Fuel cell production and testing |
Unstable test stand setup |
Service provider's time and ExperTune software |
$50,000 a year in savings |
Crystal Manufacturer saves over $75,000 per year!
Manufactures fluoride and oxide crystals.
The Challenge:
This crystal manufacturer high purity crystals. Crystal is pulled out of a
molten solution at the edge of the melting point. Tight temperature
control is critical. A cycling problem was causing the manufacturer to scrap
product that took 3 weeks to grow. A 24 hour cycle was visible by
looking at the side of the finished crystal.
The Solution:
The service provider trained the personnel. In the process of training the
service provider analyzed and re-tuned the temperature controllers.
The Result:
Savings of $75,000/year
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Crystal Manufacturer |
Crystal Manufacture |
Low yield |
Trained personnel, purchased ExperTune software |
$75,000/year |
Babcock and Wilcox user saves over $300,000 per year!
The Challenge:
This paper mill utility boiler was not meeting the performance requirement.
The Solution:
ExperTune software tests done by the service provider showed the gains were
too high on a few critical valves. Resized the valves. Re-tuned loops using
ExperTune software.
The Result:
Passed performance test of a number of hours running at certain variability at
a certain pressure and under load changes.
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Paper Mill |
Utility Boiler |
Could not meet performance requirement |
Service using ExperTune software |
$300,000 per year |
Gas Plant Solves Long-Term Process Upset
The Challenge:
Gas Plant separations units had problems with stability. This had been
a recurring problem for many years.
The Solution:
PlantTriage® software was
applied to the plant. Oscillation detection tools were used to determine the
root cause of the upset. The root cause was found to be a safety relief
valve, dumping to the Boiler Stack...very far away from the separations units.
The Result:
Cycling was eliminated at the source of the problem. Stabilized
overall plant operations, allowing capacity increase.
Read the full paper as presented at ISA 2005, Houston
Profit and loss matrix:
| Customer |
Industry Type |
Problem |
Solution |
Cost Savings |
| Gas Plant |
Depropanizer, Debutanizer |
Long-term cyclical variation |
PlantTriage Oscillation Detection |
$1,000,000+ per year |
|